•  

What is NCTC? & Why Chief Ministers oppose NCTC?

Saturday, February 18, 2012, 11:09 [IST]
What is NCTC? & Why CMs oppose NCTC?
The UPA government which is already reeling under various charges and controversies, found itself in the midst of a fresh trouble on Friday, Feb 17. Many Chief Ministers across the nation have protested the decision of setting up NCTC in their respective states.

WB Chief Minister and key ally of UPA government, Mamata Banerjee, grabbed the majority of attentions by demonstrating against NCTC scheme. [UPDATE: Crucial NCTC meet with CMs begins in Delhi]

But why these many CMs protest this system that can purportedly be an effective way to check terrorism, which is on raise in the country?

Are these CMs undermining national security interest just to protest UPA's decision or as they say it does compromise on rights of the state? Read on to find answers for yourselves.

What is NCTC?

The National Counter-terrorism Center (NCTC) was established in 2004 by Presidential Executive Order. Basically, a top anti-terror body under Intelligence bureau. The formation of this counter-terror body defy the old format of national government agencies, to make it more effective and a distinguished organisation, following the key recommendations of 9/11 commission.

It has been inducted to become a centre for joint operational planning and joint intelligence to counter terrorism that holds the staff of distinguished personnel from various government agencies.

Now, why the states oppose the NCTC concept?

As many as nine Chief Ministers of different states have ridiculed the Centre's decision to instill NCTC across the states in India. And many have already dashed off their dissent note to PM Manmohan Singh, as well.

Mamata Banerjee is also among the rebellion state heads, as these CMs presume that this prime anti-terrorists agency may clamp down the rights of their respective states.

NCTC will set up small offices across the state to gather the real-time information. It will be headed by an Intelligence bureau official and report to Home Ministry. 

NCTC officers can carry out raids without a prior permission of respective states. And the officers can arrest anyone over terrorism related cases. The state's other government authorities are bound to share details to the NCTC if required, no matter how confidential it is. Thus the anti-terror body will gather all real-time intelligence, exactly what IB is now lacking, and distribute information to other agencies, in order to have an effective system in place to tackle terrorism.

Meanwhile, it has the right to take assistance of any special force in the country including National Security Guard (NSG)

A group of nine dissent-CMs see it as "a fringe on the rights of states", Centre's "authoritarian" and "draconian", they have also suggested PM to re-look into the Centre's decision.

OneIndia News
User Comments
Achru kotwal 22 May 2012 10:22 am
security of nation was always had many doubts .... ... as i believe nctc will definitely provide vital solution in fighting terrorism.......and will make our beloved county safe place to live ...........for this both center and state should work together ....and state should understand the demand of the hour ..........that is a safe and secure nation ....
preety minhas 08 May 2012 06:34 am
if we look nctc is much beneficial 4 whole of the country it will make our country terror free. We have to also think about our countries beneficial , people are only thinking about themselves. They do not have the feeling of Nationalism.
ANDY007 07 May 2012 11:08 pm
I thought state should respect NCTC and implement it as soon as possible in naxal area, mostly in Chhattishgarh, Odisa and Jharkhand.definitely it will reducesuch incidents over there.It will bost up our plan which is being running over there. As tri-junction village like leather,garwa and balrampur which is highly affected area will soon overcome with the problem.
ANDY007 07 May 2012 11:02 pm
AS FAR AS I CONERNED NCTC SHOULD BE IMPLIMENTED IN NAXALITE AFFECTED AREA WHICH WILL HELP TO BOOST UP THE POLICE AND THE ORGANISATION WHICH WORKS THERE. BASICALLY IN CHHATTISGARH,ODISA AND JHARKAND .SOMEHOW IT HELPS TO EVICTED MAOIST IN TRI-JUNCTION VILLAG,,LEATHER,GARWA AND BALRAMPUR,WHICH CONTAIN LOTS OF VILLAGE.,
Nitin Kr 06 May 2012 11:47 pm
India has already three intelligence dept IB,RAW and CBI and we all know how these dept are functioning, in my opinion there is no need of setting up any new dept like NCTC. This is just a bad politics....
Sundeep Mudgal 05 May 2012 09:00 pm
I am finding it increasingly difficult n strange as 2 why these 9 state representatives would ever want 2 oppose setting up of NCTC! Though i fully agree that Union government should have first discussed with the all state representatives before rolling this out because this way they would have at least a higher consensus on the issue. I feel so frustrated that i feel like meeting all of these 9CMs 2 understand y they r opposing this move which is sure 2 curb the menace of terrorism 2 sme extnt
Susheel 05 May 2012 01:45 pm
"I think NCTC concept is right but its implementation is doubtful, as their is always fight between center and state government...solutions to this problem is that these agencies "NCTC" should not be accountable to politician but to judiciary...so that can work freely without any political pressure on them...."
preety minhas 08 May 2012 06:37 am
if both will work together then our countries future will look bright and I agree with u.
Mohit 20 Apr 2012 10:57 am
"Terrorist free India Or World" Its a myth nothing else. If we (our Govt.) are against terrorism then why we are spending such a huge amount on Kasab? Central has no rights to interfere in state's power. If this happen central will interfere in state's power when a state oppose some decision of central govt.
vibha 18 Apr 2012 10:38 pm
This is true that nctc is going to snatch some power from states ,but states should not forget that in this way they are going to serve their country.by adopting this nctc they are going to make their terror free.
Anurag 05 Mar 2012 03:59 pm
These 'draconian' steps if taken up, would be effective in tackling the draconian aftermath of terrorism. It is difficult to envisage a safe India in the absence of a central unit keeping track of malignant activity throughout the country. Our state leaders should understand, non-cooperation would inevitably leave loopholes in the security system killing the entire purpose of NCTC
[ Post Comments ]